Sales reach new heights
Q3 2023 consolidated results
5 January 2024
- Telematic Interactive Bulgaria AD reported 3% revenue growth for Q3 YoY reaching BGN 86.4mln. Casino revenues take the lion’s share of BGN 76.9mln or 89.1% of the total after an impressive 20.9% YoY growth. Sports-betting reached BGN 5.3mln, which marked a decline of 19.3%, but that was due to the migration to a new sports-betting platform in Q2 and Q3. The new platform has better functionalities and is expected to have a positive role in growing this business in the future. Still, this line accounts for 3.5% of the operational revenues.
- The remaining 4.7% is revenues from providing gaming content to B2B customers, which grew at 29%. The significant jump of this business line is explained by its comparatively small size, but the company has strong expectations for its potential. This account also makes the major difference between the individual and consolidated revenues.
- The main reason behind the increasing revenues is the increased monthly average active clients. The new CRM system, as well as staff training towards a more individually targeted approach, has lead to a 22% increase in this metric, to reach a total of 90,109 active clients per month. The conversion rate has stayed at the previously reported levels of 35% and the churn rate still stays at impressive for the industry levels of 4%.
- OPEX increased proportionately a notch more than sales – by 22.4% to BGN 66.6mln. The largest contributor is External services, which increased by 21.8% to BGN 40 mln but represents nearly 60% of OPEX. In that, the 3 largest sub accounts, responsible for nearly 90% of the account value are Marketing, which increased 15.2% to BGN 14 mln (35% of OPEX), Fees for gaming content, which increased over 29% to BGN 13.7 mln (34% of OPEX) and Payments services, which increased 13% to BGN 7.9% (20% of OPEX).
- External services is the account showing the expense made to provide gaming content. The company uses gaming content by external suppliers, where the compensation is based on revenue share. The larger growth of this account (compared to total revenues) is due to the one-off expense in Q3 associated to the migration to the new gaming platform.
- The lesser increase in marketing expense for the 9 months (compared to total revenues) is due to the strong marketing campaign, which was conducted in Q1 and the seasonally slower Q2.
- On the shareholder meeting on 19.12.2023 the decision to distribute a second dividend in 2023 was made – BGN 0.40 per share for a total amount of BGN 5.2 mln.
Commentary:
Currently, the company shows outstanding performance by industry standards, but there are a few warning signs we should be aware of when looking forward.
It is visible that sales growth has decreased its pace and is reaching a plateau – even though total revenues for the 9 months increased by 17.6%, the Q3 2023 on Q3 2022 results for the 3 months show increased just 12.2%. Additionally, the conversion rate dropped from 38% to 35% YoY and the churn rate increased from 2% to 4% YoY (but for the 3 months of Q3 2022 it was 1%, while in 2023 it was 5%). It is clear that Telematic Interactive is getting into a more mature phase of its development and the decisions to implement a more effective CRM system and new gambling games, which limit the loss for the casino, show that. These are tactical decisions as any decision pertaining to efficiency is tactical. Taking those steps is essential to keep their position in the existing market and remain profitable in the longer run – steps that no shareholder would disagree with.
However, the clarity over the strategic steps seems to have diminished. In their case, strategic steps would be getting into new markets or opening new lines of business, each one of which has the potential to be a game changer. Prior to the IPO, the plans were to use the vast market of Ukraine as a second step for their expansion. Because of the war there, that did not materialize and Peru was chosen as their Plan B as the company could expand to a comparable market to Bulgaria (total disposable income in Peru is 1.5-2.3 times that in Bulgaria depending on way of calculation and data sources) and to get access to large portions of Latin America.
Telematic Interactive is very open about their financial results, where they describe every metric very diligently – a feature that is not common in all listed companies in Bulgaria and for that they should be praised. The news for the work with regards to Peru, however, seem to be somewhat limited.
Additionally, the announcement on 14.12.2023 that they had signed a contract with a company in North Macedonia to start operations there seems to show that the focus is going into a less important direction – even if the operations develop perfectly in the next years, due to the 50% ownership and the size of the market, this venture can hardly offer 10% upside to the operations in Bulgaria.
We should not forget, however, that despite everything, Telematic Interactive is a superior investment. The steps towards efficiency have eroded part of the EBITDA and the Net Margin, but still the company remains a cash rich enterprise with very low debt, operating at more than 21% margin – a feat very few businesses can show. Additionally, the dividends they distribute make this one of the best picks when shortlisting secure high-dividend yield stocks. The transparency, as mentioned earlier, is commendable and top notch. In this sense, it would be very positive to see the management focus again on a step that could be a game changer as it has shown that it knows how to do gaming and has attracted decent amount of interest through shareholders, who believe in their ability.
Ivaylo Valchev
Equity Analyst
Tel.: +359 2 937 9862
e-mail: valchev@sis.bg
Svetozar Abrashev
Senior Managing Partner
Tel.: +359 2 937 9869
e-mail: abrashev@sis.bg
Sofia International Securities
Sofia 1000,
140 G. S. Rakovski Str.
Tel.: + 359 2 937 98 65
e-mail: info@sis.bg
Disclaimers and Required Disclosures
Sofia International Securities AD is a member of Bulgarian Stock Exchange (BSE) and the Central Depository of Bulgaria. The company provides brokerage, investment banking, equity research, portfolio management and other services. Sofia International Securities AD is regulated by the Financial Supervision Commission of Bulgaria.
Analyst Certification
The individuals responsible for the preparation of this report certify that: (1) all of the views and opinions expressed in this report are their own and reflect their personal views about the issuer(s) and the securities subject of this report, and (2) no part of any analyst’s compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific views or recommendations expressed by them in this report.
Regulatory Restrictions
Sofia International Securities is not registered as a broker or dealer with the Securities and Exchange Commission or NASD in the United States of America and the information may be distributed in the US only to individuals who by acceptance hereof confirm that they represent “major institutional investors” as defined in Regulation 15a-16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Notwithstanding this, no publication of Sofia International Securities AD shall be construed as an offer (or solicitation of an offer) in any jurisdiction in which such offer or solicitation would be illegal.
Financial Interest
Sofia International Securities may or may not own shares of the company that is subject of this document. The individuals who are responsible for the preparation of this report may or may not own shares of the company that is subject of the report. Sofia International Securities is not a market maker in the securities that are subject of this document. In the past, Sofia International Securities might have provided corporate services to the company that is subject of this presentation and may seek to provide such and other services in the future. As of the date of this document Sofia International Services provides brokerage services to the company subject of this document.
Equity Valuation and Risks
The value estimate(s) stated in this report is (are) valid only in light of the valuation methods used to derive this estimation. The use of other or more comprehensive approaches could result in other estimates of value that could diverge substantially from the results presented herein. With regard to the above, when making our conclusions about the intrinsic value of the Company’s share capital, we have not considered or evaluated any possible tax, legal or other effects that might arise from engaging in transaction(s) with the shares of the company. The document should not be regarded by recipients as a substitute for the exercise of their own independent judgment and they should seek and obtain independent investment advice is necessary. Any facts and/or information stated in this document are subject to change without notice and Sofia International Securities is not under any obligation to update or keep current the information contained herein. Any opinions expressed herein are only correct as of the stated date. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value, price or income of any security.
General
The report is prepared solely for informational purposes and is not to be construed as a solicitation, recommendation, investment advice or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related financial instruments. The securities described herein may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain categories of investors. The document is based on information obtained from sources believed to be reliable but Sofia International Securities do not warrant its accuracy, nor that it is a complete summary of the securities, markets or developments referred to in the report. This report does not intend to provide assurance on the value of the company’s shares or on the achievability of the projections, statements and assumptions used by us. Actual results achieved in future periods might differ substantially from the projected ones because events and circumstances frequently do not occur as expected. Sofia International Securities accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part of this report. Additional information will be made available upon request.