Excellent positioning for 2024 hurts the 2023 profitability

Q4 2023 consolidated results

7 May 2024

  • Agria’s total consolidated revenues increased 9.7% for 2023 to BGN 777 mln. That, however, includes the operational revenues, which increased 5.2% to BGN 742 mln, financial revenues of BGN 3 mln and one-off profit from the acquisition of Komers EOOD in the amount of BGN 32 mln.
  • In the operational revenues account, the sales of goods and materials, which represent the sale of grains, marked a slight decline of 0.6% to BGN 616.8 mln. The sales of production, which is the oils produced from oilseed grains, marked a very positive change of 47% to BGN 108.5 mln. These two revenue streams represent over 99.3% of the sales revenue, the rest of which is sales of services. Additionally, the government subsidies increased 65% to BGN 12.6 mln.
  • Profitability was negatively impacted by the market dynamics. EBIT and EBITDA had significant drops by 82% and 62% respectively. EBIT was BGN 14 mln and EBITDA BGN 36.5 mln. The main accounts in OPEX increased significantly more than the increase in revenues. COGS, representing 70% of OPEX, increased 10% to BGN 509 mln.
  • The picture, however, does not represent inability of Agria to transfer increased prices to end customers. The market prices of wheat, barley, corn and sunflower actually decreased in 2023 – wheat by 26%, barley by 21.7%, corn by 44% and sunflower seed by 57%. Considering the significantly increased accounts for inventory (by 37.5% to BGN 149 mln) and materials (by 77% to BGN 91.8 mln), they must have used the market slump to stock up their storage facilities – a move which can turn out to be very positive in 2024 should the price levels of the grains increase. Additionally, the new acquisition of Komers EOOD is expected to provide more opportunities for end-customer sales, which can be even more beneficial in such scenario.
  • Other major raises in OPEX came from Materials expenses (main materials going up 22.6% to BGN 112 mln and electricity, natural gas and water more than tripling to BGN 8.6 mln. The account added BGN 26 mln.
  • Hired services contributed another BGN 15 mln to the decrease in profitability. The main reason was the massive growth in logistics, which reached BGN 17.7 mln, up from BGN 7.5 mln the year before.
  • From the profitability metrics, only Net Income was affected by the profit recorded from the acquisition of Komers EOOD. The net effect of that – BGN 32 mln – is recorded after the financial revenues and expenses in the Income Statement. It is derived from the acquisition price of BGN 47.9 mln and the fair value of the assets, which included large quantities of grain, of BGN 81 mln. If the transaction is included in the calculation of the Net Income, then it would fall by 62% from 2023 to 2024, which is the official announcement. Without it, Agria would record a loss for 2023 of BGN 3.5 mln. The resulting profitability metrics, ROE (9.7%, down from 24%), ROA (4.4%, down from 13.8%) and ROIC (7.3%, down from 20.4%) dropped significantly because of the decreased Net Profit. As mentioned earlier, however, the situation of accumulated inventory and greater opportunities for sales can provide great opportunities in 2024 and it is very likely that these trends will be reversed.
  • Agria increased the bank loans exposure in 2023 significantly. The Long term loans account increased by 80% to BGN 64 mln. As per the disclosures, their interest ranges between 1M and 3M Euribor and a spread of 1.3% to 3.6%. In 2023 they added exposure to 3 facilities – BGN 10 mln on a EUR 10.32 mln facility with existing balance of BGN 7.8 mln, BGN 26.8 mln on a EUR 15 mln facility and BGN 7 mln on a BGN 8 mln facility. We do not have a breakdown of the terms of the facilities, but we assume those are investment loans and if they are to be maximized, they can possibly get another BGN 26 mln of debt from the existing facilities (assuming the remaining 13 facilities are in the process of repayment and cannot be utilized further).
  • Short term loans marked the highest increase. They rose 74% to BGN 203.6. Those are working capital facilities, which are generally used for the purchase of crops of other operational needs. If they are to be maxed, another BGN 86 mln can be utilized.
  • The increased leverage resulted in financial expenses increasing from BGN 5.3 mln to BGN 18.2 mln. The largest portion is for interest on loans, which jumped from BGN 4 mln to BGN 12.7 mln.

Ivaylo Valchev
Equity Analyst
Tel.: +359 2 937 9862
e-mail: valchev@sis.bg

Svetozar Abrashev
Senior Managing Partner
Tel.: +359 2 937 9869
e-mail: abrashev@sis.bg

Sofia International Securities
Sofia 1000,
140 G. S. Rakovski Str.
Tel.: + 359 2 937 98 65
e-mail: info@sis.bg

Disclaimers and Required Disclosures

Sofia International Securities AD is a member of Bulgarian Stock Exchange (BSE) and the Central Depository of Bulgaria. The company provides brokerage, investment banking, equity research, portfolio management and other services. Sofia International Securities AD is regulated by the Financial Supervision Commission of Bulgaria.

Analyst Certification
The individuals responsible for the preparation of this report certify that: (1) all of the views and opinions expressed in this report are their own and reflect their personal views about the issuer(s) and the securities subject of this report, and (2) no part of any analyst’s compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific views or recommendations expressed by them in this report.

Regulatory Restrictions
Sofia International Securities is not registered as a broker or dealer with the Securities and Exchange Commission or NASD in the United States of America and the information may be distributed in the US only to individuals who by acceptance hereof confirm that they represent “major institutional investors” as defined in Regulation 15a-16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Notwithstanding this, no publication of Sofia International Securities AD shall be construed as an offer (or solicitation of an offer) in any jurisdiction in which such offer or solicitation would be illegal.

Financial Interest
Sofia International Securities may or may not own shares of the company that is subject of this document. The individuals who are responsible for the preparation of this report may or may not own shares of the company that is subject of the report. Sofia International Securities is not a market maker in the securities that are subject of this document. In the past, Sofia International Securities might have provided corporate services to the company that is subject of this presentation and may seek to provide such and other services in the future. As of the date of this document Sofia International Services provides brokerage services to the company subject of this document.

Equity Valuation and Risks
The value estimate(s) stated in this report is (are) valid only in light of the valuation methods used to derive this estimation. The use of other or more comprehensive approaches could result in other estimates of value that could diverge substantially from the results presented herein. With regard to the above, when making our conclusions about the intrinsic value of the Company’s share capital, we have not considered or evaluated any possible tax, legal or other effects that might arise from engaging in transaction(s) with the shares of the company. The document should not be regarded by recipients as a substitute for the exercise of their own independent judgment and they should seek and obtain independent investment advice is necessary. Any facts and/or information stated in this document are subject to change without notice and Sofia International Securities is not under any obligation to update or keep current the information contained herein. Any opinions expressed herein are only correct as of the stated date. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value, price or income of any security.

General
The report is prepared solely for informational purposes and is not to be construed as a solicitation, recommendation, investment advice or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related financial instruments. The securities described herein may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain categories of investors. The document is based on information obtained from sources believed to be reliable but Sofia International Securities do not warrant its accuracy, nor that it is a complete summary of the securities, markets or developments referred to in the report. This report does not intend to provide assurance on the value of the company’s shares or on the achievability of the projections, statements and assumptions used by us. Actual results achieved in future periods might differ substantially from the projected ones because events and circumstances frequently do not occur as expected. Sofia International Securities accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part of this report. Additional information will be made available upon request.